As I noted in last weekâ€™s TSS debut of Raskinâ€™s Rants, Iâ€™ll be combining a one- or two-email mailbag with the traditional bullet-pointed nuggets of deep-fried ranting goodness. So hereâ€™s the best email I received last week (a long one, but a good one), followed by my response, and then itâ€™s on to the Rants:
Iâ€™ve spoken to you before via twitter (@stonemclean). With recently subscribing to RT and now this email, I am borderline stalking you. Unfortunately for you itâ€™s quite tricky to get a handgun in Canada, so donâ€™t expect any John Lennon-esque love bullets. Itâ€™s too bad because it was your best shot at trending on Twitter. (Has this joke gone too dark?)â€¨â€¨Why is Tavoris Cloud no longer knocking people out? He must share his strength and conditioning coach with Tim Bradley and Steve Cunningham. Three jacked fellas that might have trouble ringing your door bell.â€¨â€¨Golden Boy is talking about bringing Pascal-Hopkins to the U.S. BHop himself has been tweeting about the Staples Center. Is that not the worst market possible for a Philly fighter vs. a French Canadian?â€¨â€¨Speaking of conditioning coaches, now that Amir Khan has fired Alex Ariza maybe Jean Pascal can recruit him. Who let this guy out of four-round fights? Heâ€™s like a black Butterbean.â€¨â€¨Itâ€™s sad that the Jones vs. Soto-Karass / Donaire vs. Montiel card is being totally overshadowed by Pacquiao-Mosley, which will likely suck in comparison.â€¨â€¨Speaking of Pac-Mosley and John Lennon, there are some similarities there. Manny has his hair and Mosley has his reflexes â€¦â€¨â€¨Was that last one a stretch? Did I just pull a Teddy Atlas quality metaphor? Actually, if I read it back and insert an inappropriate volume swell, itâ€™s uncanny.â€¨â€¨Kudos to Tomasz Adamek for pulling the one move that legitimizes fighting Michael Grant, Vinny Maddalone, and Kevin McBride in direct succession.â€¨â€¨I was really happy to see Brian Vera upset Sergio Mora, like really happy. Was that wrong? Also, what are the chances that Bob goes through with the Pavlik-Vera fight now?â€¨â€¨Iâ€™d like to continue this but my eyes are burning due to too much scalp exposure. Itâ€™s a rare disorder, only me and one other guy suffer from it.â€¨â€¨â€”Jordan Stone-McLean
Lots of good stuff in there. As you know from listening to Ring Theory, I have a high opinion of Canadians in general and have long been impressed by the nationâ€™s per-capita production of quality comedic minds. Youâ€™ve done nothing to detract from that reputation. Some of your comments speak for themselves so I wonâ€™t respond to everything you wrote, but hereâ€™s a smattering of my thoughts on your thoughts:
The fact that Cloud has gone the distance his last three fights after starting his career with 18 knockouts in 19 bouts is not unusual; that often happens when a guy steps up from journeymen and fringe contenders to real world-class opponents. Failing to stop the trio of Clinton Woods, Glen Johnson, and Fulgencio Zuniga, who have four total kayo losses between them, is no disgrace. And as you correctly point out, punching power has little to do with the size of your pecs or biceps. Itâ€™s mostly about leverage and technique. Cloud is a good puncher, but heâ€™s clearly not the second coming of Bob Foster.
Hopkins-Pascal belongs in your home country, but thereâ€™s one American city I believe it would draw nicely in: Philadelphia. Not Atlantic City or Newark or Dover Downs, but actual downtown Philly, at the Wells Fargo Center. If they pick a date after the Flyersâ€™ and Sixersâ€™ postseasons will be over and a date that doesnâ€™t conflict with a home Phillies game, I believe Hopkinsâ€™ pursuit of history could draw in Philly. Just a hunch, but I feel like BHopâ€™s hometown (and mine) is hungry for a meaningful fight.
Youâ€™re quite correct that stamina is a major issue for Pascal (everyone conveniently forgets the degree to which Chad Dawson was coming on late in their fight before it got stopped on cuts), but I think you may have overreached using his name in conjunction with that of Butterbean. I prefer to think of Pascal as the black Dana Rosenblatt.
I donâ€™t think Pavlik has much to worry about in a fight against Vera; donâ€™t sleep on how good Pavlik can be if heâ€™s mentally and physically prepared and isnâ€™t fighting a supreme craftsman like Hopkins or Sergio Martinez (against whom Pavlik was competitive, by the way). Vera is a bit rough and tumble for Pavlikâ€™s first fight back, but I wouldnâ€™t be surprised to see Arum go with Vera for his second opponent.
I assume your last line is a reference to the one-of-a-kind scalp of Glen Johnson? As my Ring Theory partner Bill Dettloff likes to point out, that scalp seems to offer a peek inside his brain. Now hereâ€™s a peek inside mine â€¦ cue the Rants!
â€˘ Stat of the week: Fernando Montiel is 44-0-2 when he doesnâ€™t fight on HBO. Heâ€™s 44-3-2 overall. You do the math.
â€˘ Before any morons go trotting out the â€ślucky punchâ€ť nonsense for Nonito Donaireâ€™s knockout of Montiel, they should watch the last three seconds before the kayo punch landed. Montiel threw a right cross, and Donaire avoided it but didnâ€™t counter; rather, he just studied the opening his opponent gave him. When the next right cross came a moment later, Donaire ended the fight with a counter left hook.
â€˘ Something tells me weâ€™ll be seeing a few more fighters working with Victor Conte now.
â€˘ Well, I have my first ever case of tweeterâ€™s remorse. Immediately after the Donaire-Montiel fight, I wrote, â€śWhat do those who criticized Donaireâ€™s P4P ranking in The Ring over the last couple of years have to say now? Itâ€™s called an eye for talent.â€ť This was a case where 140 characters just werenâ€™t enough to say what I meant, and even in a friendly Twitter debate afterward, I didnâ€™t state my case effectively. So, to clarify: First, I wasnâ€™t crediting myself with recognizing talent; that was a compliment aimed at The Ring Editor-in-Chief Nigel Collins, who gets the final word on the magazineâ€™s rankings. And second, after further consideration, it was perfectly reasonable to criticize The Ring ranking Donaire in the top five prior to now, based on his quality of opposition. But the pound-for-pound list, unlike divisional rankings, is supposed to be heavily opinion-based, a subjective â€śwho would beat whom if they were all the same sizeâ€ť debate. And in that regard, I guess what I meant to express (but failed to do so effectively on Twitter) is that Donaireâ€™s back-to-back blowouts of Wladimir Sidorenko and Montiel have justified Collinsâ€™ ranking decision, that Donaire is every bit as magnificently talented as The Ring thought he was.
â€˘ Ref Russell Mora gets a mixed review for the way he handled the conclusion of the fight. On the one hand, I love that Mora finished his count and gave Montiel a chance to get up. A fighter is supposed to have until the count of 10 to show that he can continue, and sometimes a guyâ€™s legs are screwy after five seconds but stable after another five. On the other hand, once Mora reached the count of nine and took a look into Montielâ€™s eyes, I canâ€™t imagine what made him determine that â€śCochulitoâ€ť was fit to continue.
â€˘ Speaking of guys named Mora, I loved Sergio Moraâ€™s use of the word â€śdiminishedâ€ť to describe Shane Mosley in Michael Woodsâ€™ article on TSS last week. Some people go overboard and play the â€śshotâ€ť card before itâ€™s appropriate, but â€śdiminishedâ€ť is truly the perfect word to describe Mosley. (Just donâ€™t be surprised if â€śshotâ€ť applies after Pacquiao is done with him.)
â€˘ Iâ€™m still on the fence about how far Mike Jones can go, but you have to admit, he throws the most textbook-perfect headbutt to the gonads in the sport.
â€˘ Has Joe Goossen started mailing it in? I wouldnâ€™t have thought so, but what other excuse can there be for him not dropping F-bombs on Kenny Bayless after Bayless ruled that Jesus Soto-Karassâ€™ cut came from a punch?
â€˘ Bob Arumâ€™s attacks on HBO for televising Andre Berto vs. Victor Ortiz, instead of waiting so Berto could face the Jones-Soto-Karass winner, are completely unfair. Ortiz is a much bigger name than Jones, and physically, Berto-Ortiz is a competitive fight. (I do worry that it will be a mismatch in the mental-strength department, however.)
â€˘ Question Iâ€™d love to address in next weekâ€™s mailbag: Did anyone out there watch this past Fridayâ€™s ESPN2 broadcast on a 3D television? I have yet to find a review of the experience anywhere, so if you watched in 3D and have an opinion, please pipe up.
â€˘ Recommended reading: Chris Mannixâ€™s piece on Kelly Pavlik on SI.com, http://bit.ly/goFIX9
â€˘ And thatâ€™s enough plugging other writers; time to plug myself. Make sure to check out a new episode of my podcast, Ring Theory, this week. Dettloff and I will break down Donaire-Montiel in detail, Iâ€™ll launch a non-personal, strictly-business attack on a web site that once employed me, and weâ€™ll preview Miguel Acosta vs. Brandon Rios, Saul â€śCaneloâ€ť Alvarez vs. Matthew Hatton, Daniel Ponce DeLeon vs. Adrien Broner, and Zab Judah vs. Kaizer Mabuza. You can find the show at http://ringtheory.podbean.com/, and as always, you can scroll down just below the full episode if youâ€™d like to first take it for a two-minute test drive.
Eric Raskin can be contacted at RaskinBoxing@yahoo.com. You can follow him on Twitter @EricRaskin and listen to new episodes of his podcast, Ring Theory, at http://ringtheory.podbean.com
Comment on this article