The Sweet Science
HOME ABOUT CONTACT
EnglishRussianChineseItalianDeutchFrenchSpanishPortugueseJapaneseKorean
The Sweet Science Boxing
Boxing Podcast Boxing RSS 
tss


Sunday Nov 29, 2009


      Print this article     Email this article

Lucian Bute KOs Andrade; Guzman Gets a Gift Draw

By George Kimball

Since Lucian Bute was born in Romania, lives in Quebec, and was fighting a Mexican-born opponent on American television, it's somewhat understandable that it may have lost a bit in translation, but there's no mistaking this much: When the IBF super-middleweight champion cut loose with a devastating left to the short ribs that left Librado gasping for air while Benjy Esteves counted him out, he was sending a clear message that needed no interpreter.

 

 

Take that, Showtime!

 

 

Now 25-0, Bute defended successfully defended his title for the fourth time before more than 16,000 enthusiastic supporters in Quebec City. (His usual home turf, the Bell Centre in Montreal, might have accommodated 5,000 more, but a Canadiens game occupied the building.) Andrade, stopped for the first time in his career, fell to 28-3.

 

 

Eleven months earlier, Bute had benefited from a generous dispensation of Quebecois justice, when Canadian referee Marlon Wright was all that stood between him and a 12th-round knockout by the resilient Andrade at Montreal's Bell Centre. Despite the controversial outcome and heightened interest in its sequel, Showtime not only didn't bid for the rematch, but when that network assembled what it deemed the world's best half-dozen 168-pounders for its highly-publicized 'Super Six' tournament, Bute's name was missing in action.

 

 

He delivered his answer to the perceived slight in the main event of HBO's Boxing After Dark card in Quebec.  In their earlier bout Bute had built up a commanding lead over the first eleven rounds, only to find himself so spent that he needed the ring ropes to pull himself to his feet when Andrade dropped him in the 12th. This time the roles were reversed, and much earlier.

 

 

As expected, Bute had outboxed Andrade over the first three, but earlier in the fourth, when Andrade aggressively drove him to the ropes, Bute responded with a crisp counter-left to the jaw that nearly tore Andrade's face off. Down for only the second time in his career, the challenger got back up from that one, and even managed a sheepish grin, but with 15 seconds left in the fourth, Bute unleashed the left that caved Andrade's right side in.

 

 

Andrade, as tough as they come in this business, sank to the floor in anguish, and a proud man who had been around for the final bell in each of his previous 30 pro fights took the count on his knees.

 

 

All things considered, it was probably the most impressive performance of Bute's career, and if somewhere in the back of his mind the spurned suitor had the intent of embarrassing Showtime, his timing couldn't have been better.

 

 

It is probably only a matter of days before Jermain Taylor officially withdraws from the Super Six proceedings, and if the network, as expected, replaces him with a lesser light, they're only going to look sillier than they did when they omitted Bute in the first place.

 

 

Even were he belatedly invited, in the residual glow of Saturday night's showing, Bute would be nuts to join the party now -- and, were he so tempted, you can bet that HBO is already waving a bunch of money under his nose to make sure he doesn't.

 

 

Bute has lived in Montreal for the past six years, and the Quebecois embrace him as one of their own. And if provincial boxing officials had seemed generous in protecting Bute in the first Andrade fight, you have to wonder whether Joan Guzman secretly took Canadian citizenship papers in the past couple of days, for there is otherwise no accounting for the larceny that befell Ali Funeka in the co-feature of  Saturday night's show.

 

 

The IBF lightweight title remained vacant when Canadian judges Alan Davis and Benoit Roussel conspired to return identical 114-114 scorecards that overruled the 116-112 of New Jersey's Joe Pasquale.

 

 

Guzman, his face battered from 12 rounds' worth of punishment at the hands of the 6'1" South African, was plainly resigned to defeat and, in light of the beating he had taken, and seemed happy enough to finish the fight on his feet. Incredibly enough, Guzman remained undefeated after what went into the books as a majority draw.

 

 

Funeka needless to say, appeared crestfallen by the bizarre decision, and Bob Papa, Lennox Lewis, and Max Kellerman found themselves wondering aloud whether the scores might have been added wrong. 

 

 

Alas, they had not been. This time you couldn't even blame it on hometown scoring, but something worse: sheer ineptitude.

 

 

The bout matched two boxers whose career-defining fights had been scheduled fights against Nate Campbell. In September of 2008, Guzman was to have met the then-lightweight champion in Mississippi, but failed to make the 135-pound limit. Then, earlier this year in Florida, Campbell himself lost the title on the scale. Unlike Guzman, Nate went through with the fight. Funeka fought well enough, but ended up on th short end of a majority decision. (Roussel, ironically enough, was one of the two judges who favored Campbell in that one.)

 

 

The 33 year-old Guzman came into the fight 29-0 with 17 KO's, which seems impressive enough until you consider that three years ago he was 26-0, and that he hasn't stopped an opponent of any description in almost five years. Funeka, who appeared to have learned from his experience with Campbell, didn't begin to fight in earnest until the third, but once he did, he pretty much dominated every round thereafter.

 

 

Guzman seemed increasingly disheartened as his face sprung new leaks at every turn. A Funeka punch opened a cut along his right eyebrow late in the second. In the third, Funeka smashed Guzman with a punch up the middle, and blood spouted from his nose almost immediately. Another nick, this one on the right cheekbone, came from a fourth round clash of heads.

 

 

Referee Jean-Guy Brousseau missed the butt and ruled that it had come from a punch. Although the referee's lapse in judgement seemed to trouble BAD announcer Bob Papa, the mistake was in this case utterly inconsequential, since of all Guzman's wounds, this was the least troubling, and never threatened to stop the fight.

 

 

Funeka, who punished Guzman for ten solid rounds without meeting much resistance, had a veritable cakewalk to the finish line, and the only man in the building more shocked than Funeka by the judges' disheartening verdict appeared to be Guzman.

 

 

Funeka is left with a record of 30-2-3, Guzman 29-0-1.

 

 

The IBF will mandate another bout between the two for the still-vacant title, which will mean another payday for Joan and a delay of some months before Funeka can wrap himself with a belt which, by all rights, he should already own. Meanwhile, you can take this much to the bank: The rematch will not be in Canada.

 

 

 

*  *  *

 

PEPSI COLISEUM

 

QUEBEC CITY, CANADA

 

 

SUPER MIDDLEWEIGHTS: Lucian Bute, 166 3/4, Galati, Romania TKO'd Librado Andrade, 166 3/4, Jesus del Monte, Mexico (4) (Retains IBF title)

 

 

LIGHTWEIGHTS: Ali Funkeka, 133 1/4, East London, South Africa drew with  Joan Guzman 134 1/2, Santo Domingo, Dominican Rep.  (12) (For vacant IBF title)

 

 

MIDDLEWEIGHTS: Craig McEwan  Edinburgh, Scotland dec.  James Parison, San Diego, Calif. (8)

 

 

WELTERWEIGHTS: Keith Thurman, Clearwater, Fla. TKO'd Leonardo Rojas, Callao, Peru (2)

 

 

Kevin Bizier, St. Emile, Quebec TKO'd Patrick Cape, St. Louis, Minn. (1)

 

 

JUNIOR LIGHTWEIGHTS: Pier Oliver Cote, Charlesbourg, Quebec dec. Jason Hayward, St. John's, Newfoundland(10)

 

add to Facebook add to Myspace add to Digg add to Mixx add to Linkedin add to Yahoo Buzz


AFN:  What the Funeka is going on? Highway robbery of the finest order. Bring back hanging. Still the Guzman travesty was made more bearable by the just and fair decision in the Honorio v Molina fight on Showtime. When the scores were read, we were more shocked Honario didn't get robbed as well, than that Funeka did. That's how cynical boxing can make you. EL TOONOY
Sunday Nov 29, 2009 03:00:57 PM
MisterLee:  Did Lucian Bute look like he lifted more weights (he wasn't paper thin this fight) and maybe he sat down on his punches? His punches last fight didn't seem to affect Andrade whereas by the 3rd round in this fight they were staggering Andrade. Good fight so far... middle of 3rd round... holler!
Sunday Nov 29, 2009 03:19:21 PM
MisterLee:  Man I don't remember the last fight I've seen end with a good body shot... penalosa gonzalez?
Sunday Nov 29, 2009 03:20:30 PM
Isaiah:  I picked Bute by UD, so... close enough. Gentlemen, I hear the crow is extra fresh today. Like Campbells, mmm, mmm, good! Eat up wrong pickers. I'm still full from all I had picking Cotto against Pacquiao. Yey! It was that much crow! HA! Hey, somebody ask Floyd Mayweather if the Pacquiao fight has been signed yet! Sorry, what was that?! (::LOUD CRICKETS CHIRPING::) Bute is a beast by the way! Guzman should be thanking his lucky stars for the way the judges Funeka up the desicion. Haven't seen something that horrible since the draw with Sergio Martinez and Kermit the frog Cintron. Besides the boxers, maybe someone should test the judges for drugs, MMMKAY?!
Sunday Nov 29, 2009 03:42:14 PM
MisterLee:  Wooo.... @ Isaiah. Weren't you a big Floyd supporter back in the day? I know I was. Pc!
Sunday Nov 29, 2009 04:08:45 PM
Saul:  This is ridiculous, the Funeda vs Guzman decision is exactly why people are straying away from boxing and going to MMA. De La Hoya and GBP should be ashamed of themselves, this was either a fix or a robbery. They took so long to announce the decision that i'm leaning towards robbery at pen point. Did anyone see that suit walk over to Guzman's corner and tell him "parala" which means stop it?
Sunday Nov 29, 2009 05:11:58 PM
ultimoshogun:  It's a shame Funeka got screwed the way he did, but I'm looking forward to watching him fight again. He's like a nastier version of LTP and he's gonna spell trouble for whoever he fights. I have alotta respect for Bute now....I was thinkin he was a softy who needed the ref's help to win but he is the real deal.
Sunday Nov 29, 2009 05:27:39 PM
ultimoshogun:  I forgot to mention...word around the campfire is HBO's now pushing for a showdown between Pavlik and Bute. I say Pavlik, Bute,and LTP should have their own round robin tourny.
Sunday Nov 29, 2009 05:41:59 PM
MisterLee:  I dunno! Pavlik always has a tuneup fight with Staph, who's apparently 3-0 (3 KO's). If Pavlik can make adjustments and defeat this "Staph" he might stand a chance, that and re-occurring nightmares of Bhop, and his veteran trainer Jack "Double Jab" Loew. Holler!
Sunday Nov 29, 2009 05:45:43 PM
MisterLee:  Come on Saul, there's always fixes and bad decisions. Pple said the same thing when Rua kicked Machida's arse, and they're saying "oh no, this is why MMA is doing so poorly"... case in point: BOTH sports have bad decisions, and they won't affect the sport permanently in the long run. Holler!
Sunday Nov 29, 2009 05:47:14 PM
Yuvie:  I'm surprised at the shots that took Andrade out, especially the body shot, that must have been the absolute perfect punch. Just weird. That's the only shame with the Super Six Tournie, we won't have an undisputed champ crowned, especially after Bute's performance. As for Guzman, what can I say, I've been a fan but Funeka was a tough fight to come back to after such a long lay-off. It's a shame that Funeka was robbed though. I can't believe how some fights just don't seem to get any luck whatsoever.
Sunday Nov 29, 2009 05:49:12 PM
Yuvie:  *fights = fighters
Sunday Nov 29, 2009 06:06:07 PM
Fe'Roz @ Mister Lee:  Hatton-Castillo
Sunday Nov 29, 2009 07:41:47 PM
brownsugar:  Bute was magnificent,.. too bad he's not in the super six,.. 2nd time he's stopped a guy with a body shot,.. and that short hook was amazing,.. reminds me of the old days when a fight could change course on a dime because of one punch... but lets see if he can perform against someone with boxing skills.. Pavlik would be a good fight,.. anything could happen in that one...
Sunday Nov 29, 2009 08:37:08 PM
MisterLee @ Fe'roz:  Haven't seen it. Is it worth watching?
Sunday Nov 29, 2009 08:38:21 PM
brownsugar:  Guzman is around 35 or 36 years old,.. he walks around at 170 between fights,.. and he uses questionable methods to lose weight,.. like diuretics,.. his skill level used to be amazing,.. but he hit the wall after 3rounds last night,.. and was beaten from pillar to post untill the final round,.. he had a couple of good moments but was never in the fight after the first couple rounds... sad to see him so faded,.. even sadder to see such a ridiculous decision rendered at such a huge venue,.. the boxing public was violated and disrespected in the worst way,.. along with the hard working South African... (what purpose does it serve to keep Guzman relevant with a bad decision??)
Sunday Nov 29, 2009 08:44:44 PM
Mullen:  Ali F. Gave Guzman a beating...Bute, was Ko'd by Andrade in fight #1 boxing/ref Corruption at its finest..who ever was the promoter for fight #1 is a crook!
Sunday Nov 29, 2009 09:08:14 PM
Arturo:  I think they did that so they can make another rematch in Canada.haha
Sunday Nov 29, 2009 10:00:45 PM
brownsugar:  not taking away from Bute's win,.. but Andradae looked thinner and was trying to box more,... he was actually landing with a little more consistancy although he didn't do any damage,..
Sunday Nov 29, 2009 10:34:00 PM
Fe'Roz @ Mister Lee:  Not really but I suspect you will. pc
Sunday Nov 29, 2009 11:27:02 PM
MisterLee @ Fe'roz:  well, morales barrera, and corrales castillo are higher on my queue :). watching the guzman funeka fight now. I like how funeka bulked up. Lookslike he hasmore punch power, but how does he let fighters get inside his range so quickly? Oh well, i'm on round 3, so ig uess this is when the fight starts...
Monday Nov 30, 2009 09:47:07 AM
Jason:  It would be beautiful if Bute coult be inserted into the Super Six tournament and Jermain Taylor removed.
Monday Nov 30, 2009 12:38:16 PM

Name: Email:  (will not be displayed, TSS Privacy, your email is required to autoapprove your comment)

Please be respectful, and do not use foul language in your comment

Discuss this article in the forum

  THESWEETSCIENCE.COM   More from the Top Team of Writers in the Fight Game ...
 
More from this Writer
Columns by George Kimball
 
Recent boxing Columns and News
•  TSS Salutes One Of Boxing's Special People: Lorraine Chargin by Ron Borges
•  Sechew Powell Gets Revenge With Smart Showing Against Deandre Latimore by Michael Woods
•  Rooting For Chambers Is A Lot Different Than Picking Him To Beat Wlad by Frank Lotierzo
 
 


TSS Video
Roger and Floyd Mayweather in LA talking about Mosley fight
  
Roy Jones and Bernard Hopkins smack talking in L.A.
  
Oscar De La Hoya on Mosley-Mayweather fight and Manny Pacquiao
  
More Video
TSS Photo Archive

Angie And Goody...23 Years Later
Twenty three years later after they seconded Marvin Hagler and Ray Leonard in Las Vegas, Goody Petronelli and Angelo Dundee crossed paths again. This time, it was at Foxwoods. Photo/friend of TSS "The Iceman" John Scully reports there were only pleasantries exchanged. Goody didn't debate the split decision victory enjoyed by Leonard, which to this day Hagler disputes.

Round by Round Coverage
Manny Pacquiao v. Miguel Cotto
Fight aficionados, tune in for live, round by round coverage of the Manny Pacquiao v. Miguel Cotto welterweight championship on Saturday, November 14th beginning at 9 pm ET / 6 pm PT.

The Sweet Science Writers
The Sweet Science
Legal  | Privacy  |  Sitemap  |  Disclaimer  |  The Savage Science © 2004-2007 The Sweet Science Boxing.  All rights reserved. .