The Sweet Science
HOME ABOUT CONTACT
EnglishRussianChineseItalianDeutchFrenchSpanishPortugueseJapaneseKorean
The Sweet Science Boxing
Boxing Podcast Boxing RSS 
tss


Wednesday Dec 3, 2008

The Derry Destroyer gets the top spot from Horgan. TSS Universe, especially you Emerald Isle readers, do you agree? Weigh in!

      Print this article     Email this article

Irish Pound For Pound Top 5

By Dan Horgan

On Saturday, Ireland’s Oisin Fagan will face hot British prospect Amir Khan in Khan’s backyard of London.  In Kahn, Fagan is facing a fighter with superior power, hand speed, and financial backing (very few fighters get sponsorship checks from Nike, but those who do usually have more expensive training gear than their opponents).  But Fagan has an intangible quality that Khan does not:  a proud Irish heritage rooted in the tradition of Gaelic prizefighting. 

Throughout its history, Irish boxing has produced numerous skilled and brave warriors who have served their country proud through bloody battles and fistic fireworks.  Legends like Barry McGuigan and Stevie Collins will be forever etched in the hearts of fans for their desire, talent, and achievement.

Today, Irish boxing is still rolling strong.  Several world-class fighters from Ireland are making waves in the modern fight scene through their exciting styles.  Some Irish pugs are even knocking on the door of a world-title chance.

 With Fagan’s biggest career clash just days away, Irish fighting is back in boxing’s spotlight.  So as a celebration to the warriors of Ireland, I’ve put together a little Irish pound-for-pound list, which follows.  Ratings are based on an even basis of fighter talent and accomplishment. 

1.        John Duddy (25-0, 17 KOs):

He fights down to the level of his competition and he cuts easily, but Duddy is without a doubt a world-class middleweight.  The Derry native throws punches in bunches in every round of every fight – and every blow he delivers with conviction. 

In his most recent fight, Duddy looked strong in a ten-round thumping of the tough Charles Howe. Duddy evinced tremendous skill and stamina in the bout. 

Throughout his career, Duddy, 29, has fought at 160 pounds.  But he’s recently announced that he plans to fight six pounds south at light middleweight in his next fight, which is against Ronald Hearns in January.  Duddy’s power should be more effective at the new weight class.   

2.       Bernard Dunne (27-1, 14 KOs):

Dunne was Ireland’s hottest fighter until was blitzed in one round by Kiko Martinez in August of last year.  But don’t let the loss fool you – Dunne is still the real deal.  Against Martinez, he was simply caught cold.  A rematch could see a different result. 

A super bantamweight, Dunne, 28, has all of the tools necessary to become a world champion.  He’s a smooth boxer with robust power in both fists.   If he can continue his three-fight win streak, he has an excellent shot of contending for a title in 2009.

 

3.       Oisin Fagan (22-5, 13 KOs):

Fagan’s story is rather remarkable.  He only fought thrice as an amateur, but through sheer guts and will as a pro, he’s become one of the best light welterweights in the world. 

The road has been rather rocky for Dublin’s Fagan, 34.  Three of his five losses have been very controversial.  And all of those defeats came in his biggest bouts.

Still, Fagan has carried on, and with any luck, he’ll get a title shot before the end of 2009.  Because of his all-action, come-forward style, he stands a chance against any 135 pounder in the world, including Khan, who is a heavy favorite on Saturday.    

4.       Andy Lee (16-1, 13 KOs):

 

Lee, of Limerick, carried the world on his shoulders going into his bout with Brian Vera in March of this year.  The Irishman had a full plate of pressure in front of him:  a large fan base, the immense praise of his legendary trainer/manager Emmanuel Steward, and a possible world title shot to think about in the near future.  

 

But against Vera, everything came tumbling down. 

 

Although he is 6’2, Lee did not use his size to keep the powerful and stout Vera at bay.  Vera was able to get inside of Lee’s lanky frame to pound away at his body.

 

After six competitive rounds of back and forth action, Lee was eventually TKO’d.  His run as Ireland’s top contender was over for the time being.

 

After the loss, Lee rebounded nicely with a tenth round TKO of tough man Willie Gibbs.  But it will take more than one win for Lee to put himself back into contention.  A rematch with Vera is in order if Lee wants to erase doubts that he’s an overrated prospect.

 

Lee has an outside shot of one day capturing a world championship.  A southpaw with snappy punches, Lee can make some noise at 160 pounds if he’s able to capitalize on his immense potential.  His biggest weakness is his defense; he needs to improve his strength to keep stocky fighters like Vera off of him.

 

5.       Paul McCloskey (17-0, 7 KOs):

McCloskey is young and almost as green as the Irish flag, but many pundits, including myself, have put their faith in this smooth southpaw.  His lopsided win against former champion Cesar Bazan is his most impressive performance to date.

McCloskey, 29, has a bout scheduled for Friday against an opponent to be named.  A win plus an active 2009 could put him in position for a title shot down the road.



Fistic Fury:  "Fagan has become one of the best light welterweights in the world" HAS HE?????????? Don't think so...
Wednesday Dec 3, 2008
Irish Head:  McCloskey is fighting Colin Lynes for the European title on Friday. Fagan ahead of Lee?? Come on, Fagan was recently beaten by Kimborough. Fagan is only a part-time fighter!
Thursday Dec 4, 2008
Irish fight fan:  You've got it wrong about Fagan, Dan. He's a really genuine guy, deserves all he gets and more - but Andy Lee is in a different class to him and Oisin Fagan would readily admit that. Fagan has come from absolutely nowhere (he was a good football/soccer player), on his own, to win an Irish title and get this fight with Khan. Probably getting about 5 % of what Khan is earning tonight. Paul McCloskey won the British Light-Welterweight title on Friday night, beating Colin Lynes in England. After round three, McCloskey got the upper hand and so frustrated Lynes that the champion retired after the ninth round.
Saturday Dec 6, 2008
falls road boys:  Even though he's retired, I'd still put Barry McGuigan on the list!
Friday Dec 26, 2008
Slapbangwhallop:  Here is a more accurate Irish P4P list which has been compiled by someone who knows what they are talking about - i.e. moi! Go to wikipedia and see User:Vintagekits/Irish_boxing_pound_for_pound_rankings
Tuesday Jan 6, 2009
Bendex:  A few corrections : 1. Andy Lee ( Ireland's best prospect ) 2. Bernard Dunne ( good power in his left jab, and hook to the body but his right hand lacks power) 3. John Duddy 4. Paul McCoskey 5. Oisin Fagan (tough guy, nowher near world class)
Tuesday Feb 17, 2009

Name: Email:  (will not be displayed, TSS Privacy)

Please be respectful, and do not use foul language in your comment

Discuss this article in the forum

  THESWEETSCIENCE.COM   More from the Top Team of Writers in the Fight Game ...
 
More from this Writer
Columns by Dan Horgan
 
Recent boxing Columns and News
•  Arreola Promoter Goossen Fed Writers Pasta, And Much More by Ron Borges
•  Agebko Gives Darchinyan Run For Trash-Talking Money by Michael Woods
•  RIP, Alexis Arguello by Ron Borges
•  Calling All Klitschkos! Calling All Klitschkos! by David A. Avila
•  Arum Comments On Arguello's Death
 
 


TSS Video
Joe Calzaghe At Boxing Writers Dinner In NYC
  
Promoter Bob Arum Talks Cotto-Clottey, Margarito, Pacman
  
David Haye Surprises Manny Steward
  
More Video
TSS Photo Archive

"It Takes A Special Man"
"It takes a special man to lace them on and step into a ring to either hurt or be hurt. It's always been my opinion that the greatest fighters (not necessarily the most commercially successful) are probably born with that never give up until I'm completely done attitude. It can be nurtured over time, but you either have it or you don't. When adversity hits, and it will, this instinct will allow you to reach inside for additional strength and determination. Ali, Louis, Gatti, Corrales had it....Marquez and Pacquiao have it. De La Hoya, for all the great things he did as a boxer never had it, Tyson didn't have It, Cotto doesn't have it, and as much as I hate to admit it because I loved to watch him fight, Chavez didn't have it. 99.9% of us don't have it either. That's why we're not all fighters and we can sit here and judge these courageous men from the comfort of our computers." ---TSS reader Juan Montelongo offers his take on the Victor Ortiz debate

Round by Round Coverage
Manny Pacquiao vs Ricky Hatton
Fight aficionados, join us here on Saturday, May 2nd beginning at 8:00 PM ET / 5:00 PM PT for live, round by round coverage of the light welterweight showdown between Manny Pacquiao and Ricky Hatton.

The Sweet Science Writers
The Sweet Science
Legal  | Privacy  |  Sitemap  |  Disclaimer  |  The Savage Science © 2004-2007 The Sweet Science Boxing.  All rights reserved. .