Lara Calls For Investigation of Judge Levi Martinez

It’s Monday, two days have passed, and the ire hasn’t dimmed. Erislandy Lara is still quit angry that two of three judges saw Canelo Alvarez as the better man in their twelve round clash Saturday night in Vegas.

The judge who scored widest for Canelo, one Levi Martinez, drew special scorn from the Cuban, who went from insinuation to straight up allegation as he drew a bulls-eye on Martinez, who declared with his card that the Mexican beat Lara, 9 rounds to 3.

Lara, in many circles, isn’t getting much support, as many folks think he spent far too much time “running” from Canelo, the guy who they say was the only guy trying to make the fight a fight. The Cuban talked a great and ferocious game pre-fight, and at the weigh-in, when he said he wanted to break Canelo’s face, then and there…but during the fight, spent the majority of rounds in “don’t let me get hit” mode, rather than fighting with an intention to inflict harm on his opponent.

Steve Carp of the Las Vegas Review-Journal said he spoke to the two top men at the Nevada Commission, Francisco Aguiler and Bob Bennett, and both men said the Martinez card “concerned them” and would be studied.

Here is the release sent out by Team Lara today (Monday):

LAS VEGAS (July 14, 2014) – After landing more punches and connecting with a higher percentage, Erislandy “The American Dream” Lara (19-2-2, 12 KOs) feels he was robbed in his fight with Saul “Canelo” Alvarez (44-1-1, 31 KOs) that took place at the MGM Grand in Las Vegas this past weekend.

Fact, Lara landed 107 total punches to Alvarez’s 97 and had a higher connect percentage (28% Lara – 23% Alvarez). The body shots that Alvarez landed were grazing shots that Lara blocked with his elbows, and most of them came in the round he got cut.

Erislandy sounds off on why he feels he won the fight and deserves an immediate rematch.

“Before the decision was announced, I felt 100% confident I won the fight,” said Lara. “The facts don’t lie, I landed more total punches. Looking at it from the punch stats, you’re supposed score based on clean and effective blows landed. Most of the shots that Canelo landed were body blows that didn’t even land cleanly, and most of them came in the round where I got cut. All my punches were clean shots. I out jabbed him and boxed his ears off. The punch stats don’t lie…there is no way I lost to Canelo.”

“I’m very disappointed in Judge Levi Martinez for his horrendous score. How in the world did he score it 117-111? Before the decision was announced, I stood across the ring and saw Team Canelo and their body language said it all. You could see the depression in their eyes. Everyone on their whole team had a look of despair because they were defeated. When the final score was read, their look went from despair to relief. They knew they lost the fight, period.”

“Levi definitely needs to be investigated and he should never be appointed to judge a big fight again. I’m not sure if he’s dishonest or inept to be judging at this level, either way he needs to be reprimanded for this horrible decision. This is the second time this has happened to me and I wouldn’t want to see this happen to someone else. Like what happen to the judges in New York in the Williams fight, Levi should be suspended. I left communist Cuba to escape corruption and now I see it happening here in the boxing world.”

“Oscar De La Hoya said that I have to wait in line to fight Alvarez again because there are 10 others ahead of me. That speaks volumes because he knows Canelo got a gift.” Lara concluded. “Who are these 10 guys he’s talking about…I want to know. I won this fight and a rematch needs to happen right away.”

Strong words from Lara, using the “c” word, corruption, apparently while having no proof, beyond his heated opinion. I’m not prepared to go there, and would say, with all due respect, that Lara maight have swayed Dave Moretti, who had it 115-113 Alvarez, if he’d attacked Canelo with a similar level of fire he shared in this release, than he showed at the MGM.

As for the rematch talk, I’d be less surprised if Kate Upton reached out to me on Facebook, and expressed her desire to snuggle with me in a cocoon of enchantment than if Lara were able to secure a rematch. Canelo’s next foe will be a straight ahead banger, in the Alfredo Angulo mode, the sort which plays into his strengths and away from his obvious weaknesses.

Boxing is a sport, but more importantly to the ones who promote it, a business, a business in which “entertainment” is supposed to be at the forefront. Lara’s style, when he uses the one he used vs. Canelo, is not one that appeals to the masses..and therefore, he shouldn’t be surprised if his opportunities shrink as a result. It will be interesting to see if Lara “gets it,” or he clings to his POV on this subject…

Let me finish by making clear I respect Lara’s boxing talent, and the need for scorers to reward the ring generals, and not simply be power worshippers. But I do think Mr. Lara and a couple other guys out there who get accused of being too cute would only be serving themselves, in the popularity and revenue generating department, if they concentrated on the offense a tad bit more than their instincts direct them to do during fights.

Your thoughts, readers?



-The Shadow :

He needs to quit complaining and go investigate tapes of Jimmy Young and Andre Ward. Oh, Dandy Landy, also "investigate" how to throw more than three combinations. Pacquiao didn't act like this when he was robbed. But then again, Pacquiao knew he would get eight figures next time regardless, lol.

-riverside :

Lara style in not very Fan friendly, he got his chance an blew it!! now he is on Oscar bad side, he is not getting a second chance Vs Canelo!. Lara Knows, chances of him facing Money may are slim and None, nobody would want to pay for the fight. Shields has been around for a long time, he should of known, they would not win a track meet vs Canelo. The influnce of the fans Booing looks bad on a pay per view show. lara has risked alot more escaping from Cuba, He should of gone for broke, and taking more risks, Canelo is vulneable to getting hurt or KO. lara would on gone in with knockout mentality into the fight!!, He had a 50/50 chance of getting Ko or koing Canelo. He blew it!! With a winning result he would be in line to face Money May or Cotto $$$$. DLH is not going to do nothing for lara Guaranteed.

-Skibbz :

You're too right Riverside. Lara just crossed himself off the list of big fights. No one wants to fight him, no one wants to watch him and he brings nothing to the table. This south paw needed to do win big but he made a fool of himself wht his style and mocked the paying public. Now he's crying foul play. There's no mercy in this sport and no amount of song and dance by the loser will improve his situation.

-oubobcat :

When judging is out of line, I will jump all over it. However, I do not think judge Levi Martinez's scorecard of 117-111 is out of line. Do I agree with it? No I do not. But can I see an argument made for that card. Yes I can much like I can also see an argument made that Lara won the fight. I will state again I did score the fight for Canelo. There were also many members of the media and other fans who also scored the fight for Canelo. I have seen some scorecards, including some from respected media members, that had Canelo up 116-112. So if scores of 116-112 for Canelo are acceptable or even 115-113, why isn't 117-111 in what was a fight that had so many close rounds. From the 115-113 scorecard, that's only two rounds and the 116-112 cards just one card. Its not inconceivable. Again, I am not agreeing with that card. But its not inconceivable that someone could sit down with me, watch the fight round by round and tell me why a reason why there were 9 rounds in Canelo's favor and 3 in Lara's favor. I would argue some of the rounds but could see that person's reasoning as well. This is not CJ Ross and scoring a blatantly one sided fight a draw. Almost every round was close and in a fight with so many close rounds divergent cards that are plausible are very possible.

-amayseng :

Great comments by everyone above.. Maybe Lara should investigate to see if he ever had the Killer Instinct needed to win a fight of this magnitude. Kinda seems like he doesn't.. He blew it.

-Radam G :

"The American Dream" just need to learn that there are many mirages and nightmares in that dream. Hehehe! Even in Heaven, you had hell. That is why a hell was created to get it outta Heaven. Getting jobbed comes with the territory. The game is banana CROOKED. And ev'bodee and dey momma go apesyet when things don't go their way. There will nothing done because it's prizefighting, not fair fighting. And few, if any, will pay to see a repeat. Holla!

-The Commish :

No investigation is needed, E-Lar. Fifty percent of us saw it for you. Fifty percent saw it for Alvarez. Where it truly counted, 66 2/3 percent had it for Alvarez...33 1/3 percent had it for you. Judging a boxing match is very subjective. Your constant movement was frowned upon by judges Levi Martinez & Jerry Roth. It was rewarded, along with your quicker punches, by judge Dave Moretti. Close? Yes. Controversial? Yes. Investigation? No. -Randy G.

-flackoguapo :

No investigation is needed, E-Lar. Fifty percent of us saw it for you. Fifty percent saw it for Alvarez. Where it truly counted, 66 2/3 percent had it for Alvarez...33 1/3 percent had it for you. Judging a boxing match is very subjective. Your constant movement was frowned upon by judges Levi Martinez & Jerry Roth. It was rewarded, along with your quicker punches, by judge Dave Moretti. Close? Yes. Controversial? Yes. Investigation? No. -Randy G.
Boom. Case closed

-SouthPawFlo :

9rds to 3 is pretty much a suspect score, the 115-113 scores were more reflective of how the fight went

-StormCentre :

Good comments by all, particularly Riverside. Scoring boxing subjectively - not objectively - is one of the few legal acts (that governs fame, success and money) in the world where you don't have to be objective. Sometimes people don't understand this, but what it means is that within the realms of the rules you (or the judges) may subjectively - in other words how you see it - interpret who won the round and why. You (or the judges) don't have to explain your result in any other (subjective) terms than these. This means, Levi can say; "I saw Canelo come forward all night long, trying to make the fight and undeterred about Lara's punches, and for the most part this meant Lara's game plan was not as effective as Canelo's. Hell, even when Lara landed he still ran - you can't score a 10-9 round for a guy that does that all night". And, Levi would be (subjectively) right and therefore the case is (as it will most likely be) closed. And, despite how I can see a case for what Lara is saying, he forgets this. I think he does, because of his (highly polished) amateur style and how that emphasizes your scoring strikes whilst seeking to de-emphasize your opponent's attacks; which is - in one way - what Lara was trying to do in the Canelo fight. Problem is, when you do that you leave it up to the judge's subjective interpretation as to what your running means and also as to what your opponent's charges represent. And one thing is for sure, particularly in the eyes of judges that are unsure which way to score a 10 point must round; whilst Lara's evasiveness is up for debate, Canelo's forward charges are not. Nobody is unsure of whether Canelo wanted to make the fight. Put with my comments here
-> about how Lara was advised by Shields to do more . . . . . . What can you say? Lara, whether he is right or wrong, better be careful with these words of his, as his Cuban team mate Gamboa's experiences with Arum clearly show that there are better things you can do for your career than pi$$ off boxing's ivory towers. And since GBP just joined up with Arum, that doesn't leave a whole lot more of options for Lara. There were times when he had Canelo stunned and it would have been easier to follow up rather than run, and he simply didn't capitalize; enough to make his own corner express concerns that were themselves dismissed by Lara and/or not acted upon. This is professional, world class, championship boxing my friend. It's not a tickling or jogging contest. Here you do or die and risk the consequences of leaving it to the judges; whether you claim you're busting your opponent's face up before the fight or not. It's often that cut throat. Lara had the ability and chances to change the verdict, but didn't. He should have known all this.

-The Shadow :

Mayweather-Maidana live coverage over at the Boxing Channel.